How the Breakeven Calculation Works
Monthly savings = current P&I − new P&I. Breakeven months = closing costs ÷ monthly savings.
If closing costs are $5,000 and you save $200/month, you break even in 25 months. Any month beyond that is net savings. If you sell or refinance again before month 25, you lose money on the transaction.
Example: $280,000 remaining, current payment $1,950, 25 years left, refinancing at 6.5% for 30 years with $5,000 closing costs. New payment ≈ $1,770. Monthly savings ≈ $180. Breakeven ≈ 28 months. Net savings over a 7-year stay ≈ $10,120.
Total Interest: Why Monthly Savings Don't Tell the Full Story
A lower rate reduces your payment, but extending the term increases total interest paid. The calculator computes total remaining interest on your current loan and total interest on the new one.
When "Interest Saved (Full Term)" shows a negative number, the new loan costs more in total — typically because the term extension outweighs the rate reduction. This is common when refinancing 5–10 years into a 30-year loan back into another 30-year term. You might save $180/month while adding $50,000 in total interest cost.
The recommendation is based on net savings during your planned stay — not full-term cost. Both numbers are shown so you can weigh the trade-off.
What This Calculator Does Not Account For
This comparison uses principal and interest only. Escrow changes — property tax adjustments or insurance rate changes — affect total monthly payment but not the P&I comparison. PMI removal or addition is also not modeled.
Closing costs rolled into the new loan increase the balance and reduce monthly savings, making the actual breakeven longer than shown. The result here is optimistic if you're financing closing costs.
Tax deductibility of mortgage interest varies by filing status and income. This estimate does not model tax effects. Cash-out refinances involve a larger new balance and require separate analysis.